Profitabul vs MenthorQ: levels you can interrogate, not just subscribe to.
MenthorQ is the closest rival in futures-native gamma levels, distributing them into TradingView, NinjaTrader, and ATAS. Profitabul computes index GEX from futures options too — then goes further: the levels live on an executable orderflow chart, and a report engine lets you measure how they actually performed.
What MenthorQ is genuinely great at
- Futures-native gamma levels distributed into the platforms desktop traders already use — TradingView, NinjaTrader, ATAS integrations.
- A large education library and level taxonomy (key levels, one-day levels) that many futures communities have standardized on.
- An API and multi-market coverage beyond the index complex.
Where Profitabul covers the job
- Index GEX computed from futures options with published confidence/coverage gating — you can see when the data behind a level is thin instead of guessing.
- Levels render on Profitabul’s own live orderflow chart with footprint context, and GEX regime/node reports quantify hit rates and follow-through per symbol.
- One subscription includes the charting, data, reports, journaling, and paper/challenge execution that level feeds leave you to assemble elsewhere.
Honest scoping: stick with MenthorQ if…
- Your execution lives in NinjaTrader/ATAS/Sierra and you specifically want levels pushed into that desktop stack.
- You need MenthorQ’s multi-market level coverage or its API as a data feed for your own tooling.
The monthly math
MenthorQ delivers levels into other platforms — which means the platforms (and their data) are still on the bill:
| Tool | Plan | Monthly price | What it covers |
|---|---|---|---|
| MenthorQ | Premium | $59–$209/mo | Level feed + dashboards at current promo pricing (list is $129 Premium / $349 Pro). |
| TradingView | Plus | $30–$60/mo | A charting host for the levels (annual-billing rates), plus CME data add-on. |
| TradeZella | Essential | $35/mo | Journaling and review — not part of MenthorQ. |
| Stack total | $124–$304/mo | vs Profitabul $99–$179/mo, data included | |
Feature by feature
| Feature | MenthorQ | Profitabul |
|---|---|---|
| Futures-native gamma levels | Yes | Yes |
| Backtestable level statistics | Partial | Yes |
| Own executable chart with orderflow | No | Yes |
| Desktop platform integrations (NinjaTrader/ATAS) | Yes | Partial |
| Statistical report engine | No | Yes |
| Journaling + playbooks | No | Yes |
| Futures market data included | No | Yes |
Common questions
Is Profitabul a MenthorQ alternative?
For index futures traders, yes — both compute gamma levels from futures options. The difference is where the levels live and how accountable they are: Profitabul draws them on its own orderflow chart and ships reports that measure level behavior, while MenthorQ distributes levels into third-party platforms you license separately.
Can I still see GEX levels in TradingView with Profitabul?
Yes. Profitabul publishes its GEX levels as invite-only TradingView indicators for subscribers, so you can keep TradingView charts while the full workflow — reports, journaling, execution — lives in Profitabul.
How do I know whose levels are “right”?
Don’t take either on faith. Profitabul exposes level confidence/coverage and ships GEX regime-performance and node-freshness reports, so you can check hit rates on your symbol over the last 120 sessions before you size a trade off any level.
See it on your own charts
7-day free trial on every plan, futures data included. Or run the free report engine right now — no signup.